Should I Sell My Rental Property or Hire a Property Manager?

Last Updated: September 18th, 2025

Published on

September 18, 2025

INSTANT ADU EVALUATION

Fill out the form below and one of our team members will contact you to help get started.

The Complete Guide for Property Owners in Los Angeles & Surrounding Areas

Are you a longtime rental property owner who’s getting older, feeling overwhelmed, and unsure if you should sell your property or continue renting it out? You’re not alone.

At Boutique Property Management, we work with property owners every day who have managed their rentals for years but are now ready to take a step back. They haven’t raised rents in decades, they’re tired of midnight maintenance calls, and they no longer want to deal with difficult tenants or ever-changing California rental laws.

Before you decide to sell, here’s why hiring a professional property manager could be the smarter, more profitable option.


Why So Many Property Owners Feel Overwhelmed

Managing rental properties in Los Angeles County, Ventura County, and the San Fernando Valley has become increasingly challenging over the years. Common concerns include:

  • No Rent Increases for Years → Many owners are leaving thousands of dollars uncollected.
  • Tenant Issues → From late payments to lease violations to disputes, it’s stressful and time-consuming.
  • Maintenance Emergencies → Coordinating repairs, finding reliable vendors, and handling after-hours calls is exhausting.
  • Legal Compliance → With California’s tenant-friendly laws and local rent control ordinances, one mistake can cost you thousands in fines.
  • Retirement & Lifestyle Changes → As you get older, the goal should be passive income, not more work.

If any of this sounds familiar, it’s time to consider your options carefully.


Should You Sell Your Rental Property?

Selling may seem like an easy way out — but here’s why it might not be your best choice:

  • Loss of Steady Income → Selling means giving up a long-term source of passive rental income.
  • Capital Gains Taxes → Depending on how long you’ve owned your property, taxes could take a big bite out of your profits.
  • Market Growth Potential → Real estate in Los Angeles and surrounding areas continues to appreciate significantly.

For most of our clients, selling is not the best financial decision — especially when there’s a better alternative: hiring a property manager.


Why Hiring a Property Manager Is the Smarter Move

As a full-service property management company, Boutique Property Management specializes in helping rental property owners maximize their income and eliminate the stress of day-to-day management.

How We Help You:

1. Increase Your Rental Income

We conduct detailed market analyses to ensure your rents are competitive and compliant with local rent control laws — helping you maximize profits.

2. Handle All Maintenance & Repairs

We coordinate with licensed, insured vendors at discounted rates, oversee every repair, and handle 24/7 emergency requests so you never get another midnight call.

3. Manage Tenants from Start to Finish

We take care of tenant screening, leasing, rent collection, legal notices, and eviction protection — leaving you completely hands-off.

4. Keep You 100% Compliant

California’s rental laws are complex. We keep you protected and up to date with local ordinances, disclosure requirements, and tenant rights laws.

5. Turn Your Property into Passive Income

Stop working for your property — let your property work for you. We handle everything while you collect consistent monthly income.


Areas We Serve

We proudly manage rental properties in Los Angeles County, Ventura County, and surrounding areas, including:

Agoura Hills • Beverly Hills • Brentwood • Burbank • Calabasas • Canoga Park • Chatsworth • Culver City • Encino • Glendale • Granada Hills • Inglewood • Koreatown • Los Feliz • Malibu • Marina Del Rey • North Hollywood • Northridge • Pacific Palisades • Pasadena • Porter Ranch • Reseda • San Fernando Valley • Santa Clarita • Santa Monica • Sherman Oaks • Silver Lake • Simi Valley • Studio City • Tarzana • Thousand Oaks • Venice • Venice Beach • West Hollywood • Westlake Village • Westside • Westwood • Woodland Hills


Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Is it better to sell or rent my property in Los Angeles?

In most cases, renting is more profitable due to long-term appreciation and steady cash flow — especially when you hire a property manager to handle everything.

Q2: How much does a property manager cost in Los Angeles?

At Boutique Property Management, we offer competitive, transparent pricing with no hidden fees. Our services often pay for themselves by increasing your rental income.

Q3: How can a property manager help older property owners?

We handle everything — rent collection, maintenance, tenant issues, and legal compliance — so you can enjoy passive income without the stress.


Ready to Take the Stress Out of Managing Your Rental?

If you’ve been thinking about selling your property because you feel overwhelmed, don’t decide before exploring a smarter option: hiring a property manager.

📞 Call Boutique Property Management today: (818) 696-4498

🌐 Visit us online: www.boutiquepropmgmt.com

At Boutique Property Management, we turn rental headaches into hassle-free profits. Let us handle the hard work so you can finally enjoy stress-free ownership.

Get A Free Estimate

Contact Form